Collection: Sauces & Toppings

  • White Cheddar Cheese Sauce White Cheddar Cheese Sauce

    17 total reviews

    White Cheddar Cheese Sauce

    New!

    17 total reviews

    White Cheddar Cheese Sauce

    Regular price $4.99
    Regular price Sale price $4.99
    Learn More
    New!
  • Maui Onion Mustard Maui Onion Mustard

    560 total reviews

    Maui Onion Mustard

    560 total reviews

    Maui Onion Mustard

    Regular price $7.49
    Regular price Sale price $7.49
    Learn More
  • Horseradish Peppercorn Mustard Horseradish Peppercorn Mustard

    104 total reviews

    Horseradish Peppercorn Mustard

    104 total reviews

    Horseradish Peppercorn Mustard

    Regular price $7.49
    Regular price Sale price $7.49
    Learn More
  • Dark Chocolate Fudge Sauce Dark Chocolate Fudge Sauce

    162 total reviews

    Dark Chocolate Fudge Sauce

    162 total reviews

    Dark Chocolate Fudge Sauce

    Regular price $7.49
    Regular price Sale price $7.49
    Learn More
  • Peanut Butter Caramel Sauce Peanut Butter Caramel Sauce

    145 total reviews

    Peanut Butter Caramel Sauce

    145 total reviews

    Peanut Butter Caramel Sauce

    Regular price $7.49
    Regular price Sale price $7.49
    Learn More
  • Wild Maine Blueberry Jam Wild Maine Blueberry Jam

    7 total reviews

    Wild Maine Blueberry Jam

    7 total reviews

    Wild Maine Blueberry Jam

    Regular price $7.49
    Regular price Sale price $7.49
    Learn More
  • Chili Lime Pretzel Salt Chili Lime Pretzel Salt

    85 total reviews

    Chili Lime Pretzel Salt

    85 total reviews

    Chili Lime Pretzel Salt

    Regular price $4.99
    Regular price Sale price $4.99
    Learn More
  • Three Cheese Salt Three Cheese Salt

    75 total reviews

    Three Cheese Salt

    75 total reviews

    Three Cheese Salt

    Regular price $5.99
    Regular price Sale price $5.99
    Learn More
  • White Truffle Pretzel Salt White Truffle Pretzel Salt

    39 total reviews

    White Truffle Pretzel Salt

    39 total reviews

    White Truffle Pretzel Salt

    Regular price $8.99
    Regular price Sale price $8.99
    Learn More
  • Classic Pretzel Salt Classic Pretzel Salt

    264 total reviews

    Classic Pretzel Salt

    264 total reviews

    Classic Pretzel Salt

    Regular price $3.99
    Regular price Sale price $3.99
    Learn More
  • Mustard & Herb Salt Mustard & Herb Salt

    21 total reviews

    Mustard & Herb Salt

    21 total reviews

    Mustard & Herb Salt

    Regular price $5.99
    Regular price Sale price $5.99
    Learn More
  • Hickory Smoked BBQ Salt Hickory Smoked BBQ Salt

    8 total reviews

    Hickory Smoked BBQ Salt

    8 total reviews

    Hickory Smoked BBQ Salt

    Regular price $5.99
    Regular price Sale price $5.99
    Learn More
  • French Toast Sugar French Toast Sugar

    142 total reviews

    French Toast Sugar

    142 total reviews

    French Toast Sugar

    Regular price $4.99
    Regular price Sale price $4.99
    Learn More
  • Chocolate Espresso Sugar Chocolate Espresso Sugar

    34 total reviews

    Chocolate Espresso Sugar

    34 total reviews

    Chocolate Espresso Sugar

    Regular price $4.99
    Regular price Sale price $4.99
    Learn More
  • Raspberry Lime Sugar Raspberry Lime Sugar

    32 total reviews

    Raspberry Lime Sugar

    32 total reviews

    Raspberry Lime Sugar

    Regular price $4.99
    Regular price Sale price $4.99
    Learn More
  • Strawberry Sugar Strawberry Sugar

    4 total reviews

    Strawberry Sugar

    4 total reviews

    Strawberry Sugar

    Regular price $4.99
    Regular price Sale price $4.99
    Learn More
  • Strawberries & Cream Gourmet Topper Strawberries & Cream Gourmet Topper

    96 total reviews

    Strawberries & Cream Gourmet Topper

    96 total reviews

    Strawberries & Cream Gourmet Topper

    Regular price $6.99
    Regular price Sale price $6.99
    Learn More
  • Banana Toffee Gourmet Topper Banana Toffee Gourmet Topper

    24 total reviews

    Banana Toffee Gourmet Topper

    24 total reviews

    Banana Toffee Gourmet Topper

    Regular price $6.99
    Regular price Sale price $6.99
    Learn More
  • Peanut Brittle Gourmet Topper Peanut Brittle Gourmet Topper

    12 total reviews

    Peanut Brittle Gourmet Topper

    12 total reviews

    Peanut Brittle Gourmet Topper

    Regular price $6.99
    Regular price Sale price $6.99
    Learn More
  • Regular price $4.99
    Regular price Sale price $4.99
    Learn More

Customer Testimonials

4.7 / 5 stars